黑白密室偵探片，日本十個角色，日本一女九男，其中一個是兇手。「過去我沒聽說過這戲，為了拍《8美千嬌》，我看了一遍，令我獲益良多，對那年代的美國電影瞭解得更清楚。」（奧桑）《Marie-Octobre》很寫實，是齣沉重的電影，拍得一板一眼。奧桑往相反方向走 － 輕鬆、非寫實、七彩、諷刺（人物互相指控而來）。 同類克里斯蒂式偵探片，奧桑較喜歡佳咸美頓（Guy Hamilton：《破鏡奇案》(The Mirror Crack'd)，《午日奇屍》(Evil under the Sun)，還有Sydney Lumet的《東方快車》。《8美千嬌》參照此片最多的是佈景設計，像客廳、書房、睡房、飯廳等。
回复 :When 10-year old Olivia's Mom goes on a business trip for the weekend, she leaves Olivia home alone with her 17-year-old brother Miles in charge. The first night, Olivia falls asleep on the couch, and wakes up, not realizing how late it is. She walks her dog Charlie without Miles knowing, and witnesses a young woman being kidnapped on the empty New York City streets. Olivia runs home and tells Miles, but he doesn't believe her. The next morning, she explains what happened to local cops, and they don't believe her either! Only a cynical female detective named Dottie (played by Academy Award winner Susan Sarandon) listens to Olivia, but she too is skeptical. Undaunted, Olivia bravely launches her own investigation, putting herself into perilous situations. Her can-do spirit ignites one extraordinary adventure after another. Can she outwit the bad guys and convince her brother and Dottie of the truth in time to save the day
回复 :戏剧改编；前面受害者与强奸犯的对峙拍的异常真实，费拉·福赛特对受害者的情绪和反映均给出了异常可信的表演。但随后两名女室友的介入，话剧的感觉就全出来了，打破了原有的那股力量。室友替罪犯说话，受害者的辩护开始变得有些矫情。
松本和之
回复 :In this notorious Nazi propaganda historical costume melodrama, a conniving, ambitious Jewish businessman, Suess Oppenheimer, snares a post as treasurer to the Duke of Wurttemburg by showering the corrupt duke with treasure and promises of even greater riches. As the Jew's schemes grow more elaborate and his actions more brazen, the dukedom nearly erupts into civil war. Persuaded by the Jew, the Duke all but scuttles the constitution and alienates the assembly by lifting the local ban on Jews in Stuttgart. In a final outrage, the Jew rapes a wholesome German girl and tortures her father and fiancee. When the Duke succumbs to a sudden heart attack, the assembly of Elders try the Jew and sentence him to death for having "carnal knowledge of a Christian woman."Summary written by Kevin Rayburn
